Emotional Support Animals and Renting in Ontario: What Landlords Should Know
In recent years, the subject of emotional support animals (ESAs) has garnered much attention, especially in the context of renting homes. As a landlord in Ontario, it’s crucial to understand your rights and responsibilities related to ESAs, as well as those of your tenants. This article delves into the intricate relationship between ESAs and the Residential Tenancies Act of Ontario to provide clarity on this important topic.
What are Emotional Support Animals?
First, let’s distinguish between service animals and emotional support animals. Service animals, like guide dogs, are trained to perform specific tasks for individuals with disabilities. On the other hand, ESAs provide therapeutic benefits through companionship. While typically dogs or cats, any animal that offers emotional support can be considered an ESA.
Residential Tenancies Act and ESAs
The Residential Tenancies Act (RTA) of Ontario governs landlord and tenant relationships in the province. While the RTA does not explicitly mention emotional support animals, several related rights and provisions are applicable:
-
No Pet Provisions and ESAs: While some tenancy agreements may include a “no pets” clause, the RTA makes such provisions void (Section 14). This means landlords cannot evict a tenant solely for having a pet. However, exceptions exist if the pet causes damage, disturbance, or an allergic reaction to others.
-
Human Rights Code: Beyond the RTA, the Ontario Human Rights Code (OHRC) prohibits discrimination based on disability. If a tenant requires an ESA for mental health or emotional reasons, refusing them might be seen as discrimination. As ESAs are not considered pets but rather a therapeutic requirement, the “no pets” clause cannot be applied to them.
-
Allergies and Conflicts: If another tenant or the landlord has severe allergies or fears related to the animal, this can create a complex situation. In such cases, landlords must balance the rights of both parties, possibly requiring mediation or intervention from the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario.
What Landlords Should Know and Do:
-
Seek Documentation: While there’s no official registry for ESAs in Ontario, landlords can request documentation from a regulated health professional attesting to the tenant’s need for the animal.
-
Reasonable Accommodation: Landlords are required to provide “reasonable accommodation” up to the point of “undue hardship.” This means making arrangements or adjustments to ensure that tenants with ESAs are not discriminated against.
-
Avoid Assumptions: Never assume that just because an animal isn’t a traditional pet, it can’t be an ESA. Many different animals can serve this role, from birds to reptiles.
-
Consider Liability Insurance: Some ESAs might be breeds that certain insurance policies consider “high-risk.” Landlords should check their insurance coverage and communicate with their providers.
-
Maintain Open Communication: Establish an open line of communication with tenants. Understanding their needs and addressing concerns promptly can lead to a more harmonious landlord-tenant relationship.
-
Update Rental Agreements: While you can’t ban ESAs, you can include clauses that hold tenants responsible for any damages caused by their animals or clauses requiring the tenant to ensure the animal doesn’t become a nuisance to others.
In summary, the subject of emotional support animals in rental situations is nuanced. While landlords have rights to protect their property and maintain peace in their rental units, they must also respect the rights of tenants, especially those requiring ESAs. By staying informed about the Residential Tenancies Act and the Ontario Human Rights Code, landlords can navigate this sensitive topic effectively and maintain a positive relationship with their tenants.
Remember, this article offers a general overview and should not be considered legal advice. For specific situations or queries, consulting a legal expert is always recommended.